The Andy Eyers State Farm Agency, located in Downtown Sun Prairie, believes that when life gets complicated, your insurance shouldn’t. Our job is to help you make smart, informed decisions for your coverage and financial needs—so you can feel confident, supported, and respected every step of the way.

We follow a simple philosophy: ✅ Help you feel safe ✅ Help you understand your coverage ✅ Treat you with respect—always

Trusted, Proactive Guidance

Insurance is not one-size-fits-all. That’s why we proactively and effectively help you manage the everyday risks that matter—before small issues become big problems. Whether you’re reviewing existing policies or exploring options for the first time, we take the time to explain things clearly and help you feel good about your choices.

We’re proud to be voted the Top Insurance Agency in Sun Prairie by the Star! That recognition reflects the relationships we build and the service we deliver to our neighbors.

Coverage That Fits Your Life

At Andy Eyers State Farm, we help you review and protect what matters most, including:

• Auto Insurance

• Home Insurance

• Life Insurance

• Business Insurance

• Motorcycle Insurance

• Boat Insurance

We’ll also help make sure your coverage extends to your family—covered the right way.

Simple. Quick. Personalized.

Not sure what you have or what you need? We’ll help you review your coverage in a way that’s easy, personalized, and thorough, so you don’t miss anything important.

📞 Call or text today to get started. Let’s make sure you’re protected with the right coverage—at the right time—without the hassle.

Opening my office with State Farm in 2018, I am licensed to offer insurance in Wisconsin, Illinois, Iowa and Minnesota. My team and I help people personalize insurance plans that properly protect your autos and homes as well as ensure they are taking advantage of all the discounts available to them. I also assist our individuals in creating personalized life insurance and health insurance plans that meet their needs and make sure their most important asset is protected. We truly are a one stop shop when it comes to insuring your auto insurance, motorcycle insurance, home insurance, condo insurance, renters insurance, boat insurance, small business insurance, and life insurance needs. Call us to protect your recreational vehicles such as RVs, four wheelers, motorhomes, snowmobiles, boats, and jet skis!

Growing up in Sun Prairie, I have called it home since 1995. Being from the Sun Prairie, I understand the people here and their insurance needs. Our purpose is to serve the surrounding communities of Sun Prairie, Marshall, Madison, Waunakee, Deforest, Deerfield, Columbus, Fort Atkinson, Watertown, and Windsor, as well as the many other small towns in our area! My team and I are available to meet with individuals in the office as well as out of the office, whatever is most convenient for you.

The Andy Eyers Agency is very involved in the Sun Prairie community and love being part of such an amazing area! I work closely with the Chamber of Commerce and serve as the Chair of the Ambassador’s , as well as with other local charities and organizations, including the Sun Prairie School District. Andy is pleased to be on the Board of Directors for the Chamber of Commerce and the BID (Business improved District) in Downtown Sun Prairie.

If you are one of our amazing existing customers, we want to meet with you and make sure your coverage is keeping up with your life! If you are looking for quotes, my team and I would love to help by customizing a Personal Price plan just for you! Call or text our office to speak with us today! We are your local Sun Prairie team and would love to be your one stop shop for insurance and financial services!

If there is anything we can help you with regarding your insurance protection plan, we would be happy to assist! Please give us a call, email, text, or we would love for you to stop in the office! We look forward to meeting you and having the opportunity to earn your insurance business. Customer service is our top priority! We love being your local insurance resource! As a small business owner in Sun Prairie, taking care of your insurance and financial needs means so much to us. Our goal is to help provide simple options to your insurance coverage needs no matter how complex they are with the personal service you’d expect from a hometown company. We are also open for in person appointments in Sun Prairie!

Voted as the Top Insurance Agency in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin according to the Sun Prairie Star and their readers 6 consecutive years.

Customer service is our top priority! We continuously rank in the top 3% of State Farm Agents in the nation as a local Sun Prairie agency, offering virtual and in person appointments to review your insurance and financial needs. Reach out and see how we can help your life go right!

Chairman's Agent (2020-2025)

Ambassador Club (2019-2025)